Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Neither Fish Nor Fowl


Lindsey Davis, better known for her Falco series of mysteries set during the Roman Empire, has travelled forward in time to England’s Glorious Revolution in her latest door-stop of a book, “Rebels and Traitors.”

At 752 pages, this is a book that, if you can get into it, revels in a well-developed sense of place: England’s Civil War in the 1640’s. Charles I and Cromwell’s Parliament are engaged in a political tug of war with catastrophic results for just about everyone involved. If you like your historical novels chock-full of historical scenery, you’ll love “Rebels and Traitors.” I’d never known that whole towns such as Oxford and Chester were terrorized, their inhabitants punished and some - like Birmingham - razed to the ground for backing the wrong side. One thing is for sure: you’ll learn a lot about 17th English history reading this book.


“Rebels and Traitors” is an unusual book. Half novel, half historical narrative, Davis forcibly injects her characters into the era’s major moments with, to my mind, mixed results. The historical bits read like a rather dry factual re-telling, with the novel protruding here and there as if two books were written simultaneously, then cut and pasted together.


Davis follows two characters, Gideon Jukes (Roundhead) and Orlando Lovell (Royalist) as they fight their way across England, Scotland and Wales. Unfortunately the characters of Gideon and Orlando are constructed so similarly and their lives so paralelled, I found myself frequently forgetting which character was which. I guess this was a deliberate conceit on Davis’ part: telling the story of two simple men at the mercy of history. But stupid me, I just kept mixing them up.


But maybe you won’t have that problem. At page 200, I thought I probably wouldn’t finish it. At page 300, I was sure I wouldn’t finish it. I’m up to page 400 now. Will I finish it? Ask me when I get to page 500. Or 600. Or 700. Then I’ll have just 52 pages to go.


Click here to reserve “Rebels and Traitors”, although I can’t promise exactly when I’ll finish it.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.