Wednesday, September 15, 2010

False Mermaid by Erin Hart


The tale of a nineteenth century Irish housewife who was said to be a selkie is interwoven with the unsolved murder of pathologist Nora Gavin’s younger sister in the newest mystery by Erin Hart.
False Mermaid is the third book in the Nora Gavin series, but can be read as a stand-alone.

Triona was found dead in the trunk of her car three years ago, and the details surrounding that time are gradually developed through flashbacks to Nora’s memories. In particular, Nora is fixated on her sister’s husband, Peter Hallett. She has deep suspicions about Peter’s guilt, but the police have no evidence to link him to the crime scene, and the rest of her family professes to believe in his innocence. Nora fled to Ireland to focus on her work on bog bodies, but now returns to Minnesota in a final effort to get to the bottom of what happened.

Left behind, Nora’s boyfriend Cormac has family problems of his own. The sudden illness of his estranged father leaves him unable to follow Nora to the States, and he finds himself in the company of his father’s house guest, a university professor researching folktales about selkies. In tales and songs, selkies were seals who could strip off their sealskins and become human. If the sealskins were lost or stolen, the selkies would be trapped in human form until they could win them back. Cormac helps Roz get to the bottom of the tale of Mary Heaney, a woman who lived around the turn of the nineteenth century who was said to be a selkie after she disappeared.

The interwoven plots are enjoyable and interesting, especially for those who have an interest in Ireland or folklore. I found that some of the pieces of the central mystery seemed to fit together awkwardly, causing Nora to leap to unwarranted-- yet invariably correct!-- conclusions, so if you’re in it purely for the Sherlockian logic of it, this might not be the book for you. However, the suspense level is high, the writing is crafty, and there’s even a bit of a twist at the end.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.