Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Desperate disease, dangerous remedy



Siddhartha Mukherjee's astonishing and ambitious book, The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer, tells the story of mankind's long and awful confrontation with cancer. A physician, he intersperses the historical story with vignettes from the lives of his own patients. Both of these narratives are horrible and fascinating.

This book is at its most engrossing in its description of the 20th century's War on Cancer, a well-funded, highly-publicized attempt to cure cancer with one mighty scientific push, a Manhattan Project for cancer. The effort has so far, obviously, failed. Mukherjee praises those who made breakthroughs, and he is unstinting in his criticism of all the blind alleys and blunders into which researchers stumbled due to arrogance, wishful thinking, and refusal to cooperate.

I was amazed and appalled to discover that, until the very end of the 20th century, attempts to treat and cure cancer were not informed, at all, by any understanding of what caused cancer, how it worked, or how it spread. For instance, throughout the first half of the 20th century attempts to find a surgical cure for breast cancer led to more and more and more extensive surgeries. The mastectomy became "an extraordinarily morbid, disfiguring procedure in which surgeons removed the breast, the pectoral muscles, the axillary nodes, the chest wall, and occasionally the ribs, parts of the sternum, the clavicle, and the lymph nodes in the chest."

Because surgeons did not understand the mechanism of metastasis, they did not realize that such extensive surgery would not work if it was performed after the cancer spread to other organs; and if it was performed before the cancer spread, it wasn't necessary. Only very gradually has the ethos of radical surgery been abandoned; some surgeons are still today reluctant to let go of extensive cutting, even in the face of evidence that it doesn't improve patients' chances.

Just as nightmarish, in a different way, were the chemotherapy trials of the 1960s. Doctors, again not knowing the cause or mechanism of cancer, would produce cocktails of three, four, or five deadly poisons and test them on children dying of leukemia. They made progress, but what terrible risks they took.

Mukherjee explains complicated scientific concepts in a way that's easy for the layperson to understand, and his story is riveting. He explains what makes a good screening test (and why the mammogram is not always a very good one); how AIDS activism in the 1980s affected cancer research; why intensive chemotherapy is more frequently effective for leukemia and lymphoma than for breast and lung cancer; and why cancer can be caused by everything from viruses to bacteria to cigarette smoke.

I wouldn't call this a pleasant read - The Emperor of All Maladies had me compulsively checking my glands - but it is endlessly interesting. Even as I shuddered, I still could not put it down.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.