Showing posts with label fantasy fiction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fantasy fiction. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 19, 2013

Under Heaven by Guy Gavriel Kay





I was tricked into reading a fantasy book. Under Heaven, by Guy Gavriel Kay, sports one of Newport Library’s distinctive purple dragon genre labels on the spine. Yet the blurb inside the jacket cover reads more like historical fiction. I’m not into dragons, but I was curious.

In an alternate Tang Dynasty China, Shen Tai honors his dead father, a famous general, by burying the scattered bones of slaughtered soldiers who fought at a remote mountain battlefield. In gratitude for this two-year long selfless act, the enemy Taguran kingdom gives him a gift of incalculable value: 250 Sardian horses.

Wending his way back to the capital Xinan, Shen Tai must navigate the slippery slope of a court political scene more treacherous than any high mountain trail. Why has Spring Rain, a courtesan and old friend, sent out a Kanlin warrior women to protect him? And how has Shen’s older brother suddenly become an advisor to the new chief minister Wen Zhou, who has taken Spring Rain as his concubine? What will Shen Tai do with the horses, and to what lengths will others go to take them away from him?

These political and moral questions are embroidered within a classical Chinese aesthetic. Aside from a little ghostly magic that saves Shen’s life early on, Under Heaven reads more like an elegantly staged political thriller than a woo-woo fantasy novel. And not a wizard, witch or warlock in sight. And best of all: no dragons! I’m liking it.

You can reserve Under Heaven here.

Wednesday, February 27, 2013

Kingkiller Chronicle Redux

A year ago I blogged about The Name of the Wind, the first book of Patrick Rothfuss’ Kingkiller Chronicle. It took me thirteen months, but I finally read book two, The Wise Man’s Fear. And I feel even more ambivalent. There are so many things I don’t like about this trilogy—even things I hate!—and yet if book three were going to be released tomorrow, I’d be camped out in line at the bookstore by midnight tonight.

 A quick summary: Kvothe was born into a traveling players’ troupe. When he was eleven, the entire troupe, including his parents, was murdered by a group of immortal evildoers who most people consider to be a fairytale. From that point onward, Kvothe bent his life toward mastering the sophisticated magics taught at the University as the only road to knowledge and revenge.

In the present, Kvothe is an innkeeper, a hero in hiding, relating the story of his life to a scribe over a period of three days (one day per volume of the trilogy.) We know that there are currently problems in the lands: impossibly high taxes, unsafe roads, distant war, and unnatural creatures that fear iron, but we don’t yet know how Kvothe ties into any of that, or how he might solve it.

The majority of the story is the past, as told by the innkeeper. In The Name of the Wind, Kvothe relays how he made his way from the site of his parents’ murder to being a street-beggar to being a student at the University. In The Wise Man's Fear, he tells of his seeming success at the University, until an ongoing and dangerous feud with another student forced him to take a leave of absence to let things cool down. He went to distant Vintas, where he vied for the patronage of a nobleman, and found himself drawn into tangent after tangent.

 I don’t want to spoil the book by giving too much detail. Let’s just say—there are wonderful things about Rothfuss’s storytelling and world-building. He’s an idea man—he enjoys exploring philosophical concepts through character interaction. The downside is, it makes the story feel very picaresque or episodic—one nearly random event after another, to force the character to learn and grow in whatever way serves his impending hero-hood. And each episode goes on for hundreds of pages (this is a 994 page book.) I spent a good deal of the book thinking, can we go back to the University now?

Ultimately I thought the books could have been edited a lot more tightly, both plot-wise and sentence-wise, and perhaps been broken up into more volumes—maybe even a triple trilogy, รก la Donaldson’s Thomas Covenant series. Nevertheless, Kvothe is a strong and charismatic character, whose clever voice, human flaws, and audacious risk-taking overcome the occasional weakness in the writing and plot.

In my previous post on The Kingkiller Chronicle, I said book three was coming out in March of last year, and I apologize. I don’t know where I saw that, but it appears publication dates on the third book were tentatively set for May 2013 but have been pushed up to an unannounced date, possibly next year.

Wednesday, October 10, 2012

Dark Glamour


The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern is about a deadly rivalry between two ancient enemies, a strange circus, and a forbidden love.

The two enemies are magicians who have developed differing schools of thought. To ascertain which is right (and it is essential to them that one of them be right), they each adopt a child and bind it to a lifelong magical competition. The two children, Marco and Celia, are cruelly trained throughout their childhoods to defeat the other.

The magical competition results in Le Cirque des Reves, which mysteriously appears in a random location, opens at night, and closes at dawn. In the black-and-white circus tents, customers encounter some of the usual circus acts - contortionists and fortune-tellers - but there are also a variety of experiences that can only be magical. An endless labyrinth of rooms, some filled with trees, some with snowstorms, some with burning desert sands. A bonfire that burns with multicolored flames and without apparent fuel. A wishing tree covered with flickering candles; when you make a wish, a candle lights; when your wish comes true, the candle is extinguished. Et cetera.

These strange exhibits were created by Marco and Celia, competing and, eventually, collaborating. The two realize that they cannot just make circus spectacles forever; one of them must win, the other lose. Is there any way for them to escape the onus to which they are bound?

My favorite thing about the novel is the way that the intricate dance between Celia and Marco gradually enmeshes other people. Drama builds as our protagonists must try not only to escape their own fate but keep others from getting hurt or killed in the process.

 Unfortunately, I was less enchanted by the actual circus than I was supposed to be. I’m afraid I don’t really like circuses very much, and I found myself skimming some long descriptions of supposedly-wondrous circus delights. I was relieved to find no magical clowns.

Morgenstern’s novel of love, hate, and magic is dreamlike, endlessly creative, and sometimes a little slow. Her goal in The Night Circus is to immerse the reader in another reality, and she succeeds. Though her constant evocation of marvels seems a little stifling, I can promise that The Night Circus is not quite like anything else you’ve ever read.

Tuesday, June 26, 2012

It's a big enough umbrella


Alexia Tarabotti, heroine of Soulless, is not your typical English rose. Cursed with Mediterranean skin like her Italian father, an ample figure, a large appetite and... er...nose, she is resigned to spinsterhood.

Miss Tarabotti goes to a ball and is chagrined to find that there is nothing to eat but watercress! Really, how cheap can a host be? Never one to suffer, Alexia orders a treacle tart in the library, where to her irritation she is interrupted by an ill-mannered and ill-informed vampire. He is not properly introduced when he attempts to dine on Miss Tarabotti; nor is he conversant with her special talent.

Miss Tarabotti, in a world of normal people and supernatural people (those who have excess soul), is unique: she has no soul at all. When she touches a supernatural, they become normal.

In her attempt to discourage this ignoramus with her trusty umbrella, Miss Tarbotti accidentally kills him. She is soon enmeshed in a mystery of unknown proportions. Hive Queens, mad scientists, disappearing vampires, rogue vampires, werewolves, and that paragon of imperial power herself, Queen Victoria, all whirl in a merry-go-round of plot twists and surprises.

This first novel by Gail Carriger was a delight to read. Soulless is a wild combination of comedy of manners, paranormal romance, alternative history, urban fantasy, and steampunk. I loved the comic tone of this book. With all the ponderous, ominous paranormal novels out there, this one stood out for sheer fun!

Monday, May 7, 2012

Move me onto any black square


Myfanwy Thomas opens her eyes to find herself surrounded by corpses, with no idea who she is or how she got there. She finds a letter in her pocket, from the person she was before she was struck with amnesia, giving her instructions.

That’s the opening of The Rook, a very entertaining action-adventure-fantasy novel from Daniel O’Malley. Myfanwy (rhymes with Tiffany) is a Rook in the chess-themed top-secret agency whose mission is to protect Great Britain from supernatural peril. The old Myfanwy learned that she was going to be betrayed by one of her colleagues and struck with amnesia, so she began to make detailed notes and instructions for the new Myfanwy to follow. The narrative of the novel alternates between new Myfanwy’s experiences and old Myfanwy’s letters.

Myfanwy must cope with the normal challenges of her job - England is under constant assault by all sorts of horrors - along with maintaining the secret of her amnesia, and finding out who is responsible. Matters are made more difficult by the fact that the old Myfanwy was a tearful wimp, respected by no one.

The problem with amnesia books - this one included - is that what the amnesiac does and does not remember sometimes seems awfully convenient. Myfanwy doesn’t remember that vampires and sentient purple fungi are real, but she does remember how to use a cell phone, drive, and check her bank balance at an ATM.

If you can accept that, The Rook is packed with action and often very funny. The idea of a secret organization tasked with combating monsters is not very new -- hello, The Initiative from season four of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. But I bet fans of Buffy would really enjoy The Rook, with its smart-mouthed heroine and constant onslaught of slime-oozing bad guys. It has the same sense of whimsy amid the gore.

I got interested in The Rook when I read an interview with Daniel O’Malley, who described his method of coping with boring work meetings: he would pretend he wasn’t really himself. This got him to thinking: How would you go about impersonating yourself? What would you need to know to pull it off successfully?

The Rook was the result of these somewhat unprofessional musings, and it is great fun.

Friday, April 27, 2012

Reckless by Cornelia Funke

Cornelia Funke's Reckless takes place mostly in a Mirrorworld of grim fairy tales, where Sleeping Beauty died waiting for her kiss while more than one mummified prince moldered in the thorn bushes. It's a novel of few notes, but all of them true.

In the real world, Jacob Reckless’ father disappeared, and Jacob became the man of the house too young. Then he discovered the Mirror in his father’s study, that allowed him to escape his mother’s grief and his little brother’s neediness. He spent as much time adventuring in the Mirrorworld as he could, until he and his brother were both grown and their mother passed away.

Now, Jacob’s younger brother Will stumbles onto the Mirrorworld for the first time, drawing his girlfriend Clara behind him. They think they’ve discovered a beautiful fairy tale, but only Jacob understands the dark consequences of their mistake. The Mirrorworld has always been dangerous, but now it’s also in the middle of a civil war, as the long-despised stone-skinned Goyls are given new strength from the Dark Fairy, and the merest scratch of a Goyl’s claw can transform human skin to stone.

Funke’s book does not delve into the real world lives of Jacob, Will, and Clara: it maintains its fairy tale focus all the way through, playing on archetypes rather than specifics. Jacob's life in the Mirrorworld comes across as grim and empty, so that it seems he fled his real-world home for an adventure with as much meaningful human interaction as a video game. The characters develop only slightly over the course of the book, and if there is a happy ending, it’s the bittersweet kind.

Nevertheless, it’s a beautifully written dark fairy tale, which might appeal to fans of the movie Pan’s Labyrinth. Funke (FOON-ka) is a German author whose writing for children has been very well received in the United States, where she is perhaps best know for her Inkworld trilogy. Reckless is categorized as Young Adult, but will appeal to adult fans of fantasy as well.

--Posted by Stacy

Friday, April 6, 2012

No one writes books like Patricia McKillip any more.


I think lyrical epic fantasy novels mostly went out after the '80s. Nancy Springer and Tanith Lee have moved on to other things, but McKillip carries on writing gorgeous tapestry-like fantasy novels, each one lovelier and more magical than the last.

The Bards of Bone Plain concerns a bustling college of music, located on a windy plain studded with strange standing stones.

Phelan Cle is ready to graduate from the school and move on with his life, while his alcoholic, absent father Jonah busies himself with digging up archaeological wonders from beneath the city. Phelan's final research paper concerns the ancient poems and bardic tales of the realm, including the oldest of them all, the strange riddle-song of Bone Plain.

Legend has it that centuries ago, the bard Nairn failed the riddle-challenge of Bone Plain and passed into legend as the Wanderer, the Cursed, the Unforgiven Bard.

Phelan's research into the fate of Nairn begin to intertwine with events in his own day. The realm's Royal Bard suddenly decides to retire, and a great bardic competition is arranged to select the new Royal Bard. A strange, dark-eyed bard named Kelda obviously wants to win. Is Kelda using magic to influence the competition? What does Kelda know about Nairn? And what does Jonah Cle have to do with all this?

McKillip's books look rather lightweight, bedecked with flowery maidens on their covers. If you've overlooked them, don't - McKillip has won a slew of awards, including, twice, the World Fantasy Award. Her books have been favorites of mine since I was a teenager.

Give The Bards of Bone Plain a try: it is beautiful.

Thursday, February 23, 2012

Black fantasy


Not for you, the golden glades of Lothlรณrien, where the elf-queen rules amid the dream-flowers? Looking for something grittier? Try White Cat and its sequel, Red Glove, by Holly Black, for fantasy that owes a lot more to the shadowy world of The Sopranos than to Tolkien.

Cassel Sharpe is a smart teenager, trying to stay out of trouble and fit in at his expensive boarding school. But that's not easy for a kid from a family of con artists, killers, and curse-workers.

You see, magic is illegal but available through organized crime channels; if you want curse-work done, you need to make a bargain with the mafia. Cassel is inextricably connected to the mob by blood, even though he doesn't do work himself. He'd like to avoid the business, in spite of his complicated loyalties to his family.

Most fantasy novels present magic as basically neutral - a tool that can be used either for good or evil. But in these novels, it's hard not to see the inherently malignant implications of curse-work: you can tamper with someone's memories; or make them feel emotions that they otherwise wouldn't; or, you know, murder them, in either straightforward or devious ways. This seems to be dark power. Maybe people who can't do it are right to be afraid of those who can.

The more we learn about Cassel, the more we suspect that someone has been working on him. He's in up to his neck - he just doesn't know it.

White Cat and Red Glove present a malevolent and dangerous world, in which no one is innocent and no one can be trusted. I'm excited to grab the third book, Black Heart, but unfortunately I'll have to wait - it's not out until April.

Saturday, November 26, 2011

Zone One by Colson Whitehead


Mark Spitz (not his real name) is a sweeper: an armed and armored warrior tasked with a building-by-building hunt, clearing zombie stragglers from the part of Manhattan called Zone One.

The rest of Manhattan, like the rest of the world, is overrun with the undead. The global zombie apocalypse has come, and only a tiny percentage of humanity remains. Like Mark Spitz, the survivors are traumatized wrecks; they have lived not because they are the best and brightest, but because they are the most ruthless, the most stubborn, the most able to walk away from everything they once loved. Mark Spitz was a slacker in a meaningless job before the end of the world; now he is a lean and hardened killer, ready at any moment to grab his pack and move, and only troubled a little by hallucinations.

Zone One by Colson Whitehead is a zombie apocalypse novel; but its real subject is the struggle of the shattered remainder of humanity to rebuild society after the apocalypse. Whitehead views this prospect with a cynical eye. He notes that the new provisional government has given itself a theme song, entitled "Stop! Can You Hear the Eagle Roar? (Theme from Reconstruction)".

The effort to resuscitate Manhattan may be a bright beacon of humanity's struggle to create a new future; or it may just be a publicity stunt, designed to distract those who remain from their imminent destruction.

Colson Whitehead is the author of one of my very favorite novels ever, The Intuitionist. (See my review here.) Zone One is not quite that good; it tends to proceed in a scramble of interlayered flashbacks. The reader sometimes has to stop and sort out when and where she is, which drains away the book’s forward momentum.

But there are a lot of novels about zombies out there, and this is one of the best. Whitehead is terrific writer, and for darkly funny grimness, there's no one better.

I recommend a two-book binge: for a detailed, harrowing account the unfolding apocalypse itself, start with World War Z: An Oral History of the Zombie War by Max Brooks; and for the shambling aftermath, Whitehead's Zone One.

And then, you can probably in all fairness say that you have done the zombie thing, and move on to the next hot trend.

Monday, October 24, 2011

Trickster's Choice by Tamora Pierce


Alianne of Pirate's Swoop is bored. Daughter of the legendary Lioness of Tortall, she's sixteen and ready for adventure - only her protective parents won't let her go find it.

Then she is seized by pirates, sold into slavery, and confronted by a trickster god, who makes her a wager: if she can keep her current master's children safe for one summer, she will be freed and returned home. Aly thinks it sounds like an easy bet - how hard could it be to keep four kids alive for a few months?

But the children of Duke Mequen Balitang are special. The eldest girls, daughters by his deceased first wife, are the last of an ancient royal line. Prophecy suggests they may come to power in the Copper Isles, ousting the current, fading Rittevon monarchy. With plots and conspiracies swirling around the girls, how will Aly win her wager and get home again at last?

Trickster's Choice is an action-packed fantasy adventure that takes place in the well-realized Tortall universe. Author Tamora Pierce has already explored Tortall in several other fantasy series, like Song of the Lioness and Protector of the Small.

It's delightful to read a fantasy novel led by a smart, capable, brave heroine like Aly. If I have a complaint about Trickster's Choice, it's that Aly's a little too capable: she knows how to speak several languages fluently, pick locks, break codes, fight with daggers, sew, read lips, play chess, herd goats, and catch thrown knives from the air. In fact, Aly never encounters anything she can't do in this whole book. You can't have much of a character arc with a character who already knows everything. Even Indiana Jones was afraid of snakes.

Nevertheless, Aly's humor and spirit help make Trickster's Choice an exciting and fun read. It's the first of a two-part series: I'm going to start its sequel, Trickster's Queen, today.

Monday, August 8, 2011

Welcome back to Bordertown

I remember how refreshing and different Bordertown was, when I was a teenager.

Back then - this was in the early 1980s - I read a lot of fantasy novels. They tended to be deeply influenced by Tolkien's Lord of the Rings trilogy. Stephen R. Donaldson, Patricia McKillip, Terry Brooks, Katherine Kurtz - they all depicted magical worlds modeled on medieval Europe. There were kings and queens, knights and ladies, not to mention wizards and elves, going on quests and facing down magical threats in imaginary landscapes. I read them all.

The first Bordertown anthology, Borderland, was edited by Terri Windling and came out in 1986, and how unusual it was. Here was fantasy that took place in a modern city, amid the highways and bars and bands and apartment buildings and factories. Urban fantasy isn't that unusual now, but at the time it was strange and delightful.

Bordertown is a city in the NeverNever, the fey area where the World meets the Elven Realm, where neither magic nor human technology seem to work properly. To this city come the riffraff of both worlds - runaways, rejects, halflings, and seekers of all kinds. They figure out who they are, build new communities in exile, and try to steer clear of the gangs and addicts.

There were several Bordertown anthologies, featuring stories by well-known fantasy authors of the day. The format of the books is just as interesting as the setting - lots of authors wrote their own stories, sharing the setting. The books are mostly out of print now, and very hard to find (though the Tillamook County Library has this one).

After a long hiatus, a new Bordertown anthology has come out. Welcome to Bordertown features stories by some of my favorite authors from the old anthologies - Ellen Kushner, Emma Bull, Will Shetterly, and Charles de Lint. It's also picked up stories by some other authors who, like me, enjoyed the series back in the day - Neil Gaiman, Cory Doctorow, Holly Black, and Catherynne Valente.

My favorite story is "Incunabulum" by the always-excellent Emma Bull, in which an elf in a bloodstained shirt finds himself in Bordertown, furious, frightened, and unable to remember his name or how he came to be there. His attempt to steal a clean shirt starts him on the road to self-discovery.

If you're an old fan of Bordertown - or if you've never heard of it, but are intrigued by the idea - check out Welcome to Bordertown. It's lots of fun.

Friday, May 27, 2011

Torn with briers, I can no further crawl


Three woeful losers, Henry, Will, and Molly, enter Buena Vista Park in San Francisco, where they get lost. It is not a very large park, but it lies under an enchantment. The faerie Queen, Titania, has lost her Boy to leukemia, and in her intolerable sorrow and rage, she has committed a rash act. The faeries panic, because Titania has released the malevolent Puck. Molly, Henry, and Will are in trouble.

The Great Night by Chris Adrian is obviously an updated version of Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream. It is not a sparkly magical comedy of lovers’ folly, but a darker and more tormented experience. Tatiana's grief at the death of her changeling child transforms not only her own life but nature itself. The faeries are pitilessly amoral, indifferent to human suffering but dangerous in their own. The heart of the book is the section in which Oberon and Tatiana camp out in the pediatric cancer ward, as furious and helpless as any merely human parents.

Puck is no merry wanderer of the night, but a terrifying force of evil, whom even the king and queen fear. As the three humans wander through the park, their stories are told in long flashbacks: how they came to be so brokenhearted, what they did wrong that brought them here. They do not know each other, but clues reveal that they are intimately connected nonetheless.

As in A Midsummer Night's Dream, comic relief is supplied by a play within a play. In this case, a loose band of homeless people plan to expose the mayor's corruption by way of a musical. They, too, get swept up into the magic.

The Great Night is an imperfect novel. Its plot is a little muddled; often the flashbacks seem much more immediate, more real, than the things that are happening to our protagonists in the present moment. It's also a very sexually frank book, with graphic descriptions that don't always serve the plot very well. Still, it's a remarkable read, witty and heartbreaking at once.

Thursday, March 3, 2011

A queen in a fairy tale

There is a timeless faerie-world. It exists side-by-side with our own world, and sometimes denizens from that world visit ours, often to make mischief; for though they are lovely, their laws and customs are not ours. We know this, not just from such old tales as Tam Lin, but also from lots of urban fantasy novels, including Terri Windling's Borderland series, War for the Oaks by Emma Bull, and Changeling by Delia Sherman, in all of which modern urban dwellers encounter Sidhe magic. Except the Queen by Jane Yolen and Midori Snyder is a charming addition to this tradition. The Queen of the Seelie Court once mated with a mortal man. Two beautiful, feckless fae sisters, Serana and Meteora, stumble upon this secret, and so the all-powerful Queen banishes them to American cities. They find themselves lost, bewildered, separated, stripped of magic, and trapped in the bodies of old ladies. Meteora and Serana - now known as Sophia and Mabel - quickly find that they do not like being old ladies.

Watching the fae princesses adjust to twenty-first century life is very entertaining. I loved their bewildered attempts to make sense of the world. They also send letters to one another that are loving and sorrowful and sometimes snippy. Very sisterly. (The letters get especially good once they stop using carrier pigeons and figure out the U.S. Postal Service.)

In fact, I so enjoyed Mabel and Sophia that I didn't really welcome the appearance of the actual plot. As so often happens in books like this, good and bad faeries are embroiling mortals in their struggles, and a Big Showdown is coming. That's fine, but the real joy and humor of this book comes from the two sisters.

I believe that Yolen and Snyder each took a sister; Serana and Meteora have different voices that I suppose come from having been written each by a different author. I also think that Yolen and Snyder had a lot of fun writing this book, and the result is a book that, while it doesn't exactly break new ground, is a lot of fun to read. If you like urban fantasy and good writing, take a look at Except the Queen.

Monday, December 6, 2010

A little bit (two inches wide) of ivory

I love Jane Austen, and I rarely read Austen pastiches - you know, sequels to Austen's novels, or Austen's novels retold from different points of view. These are authors' hopeless love letters to Austen, and I sympathize. But without Austen's brilliance, such books are just a tiny bit boring.

(I know that's a controversial statement. The opinions here expressed do not represent the opinions of the Library or anyone else at all, possibly. But I stand by them.)

Austen's novels are about parties, and picnics, and gossip, and dresses, and who's going to marry whom. Middle-class Georgian English ladies were not supposed to be interested in politics, the stock market, the war, the latest news, or anything interesting. They were largely confined to what made them attractive to potential husbands: their looks, their clothes, their manners, their accomplishments. Attracting the right husband was the most important decision of their lives - until it came time to attract husbands for their daughters.

This is Austen's genius: she shows what a triumph it was for women in such narrow circumstances to grow up straight and true (like Lizzie Bennett) and not neurotic and vapid (like Lizzie Bennet's mother). Emma, Austen's best book, is about a strong and opinionated woman who makes a serious mess out of things, mostly due to sheer boredom.

All of this brings me to a new novel by Mary Robinette Kowal, Shades of Milk and Honey. The plot will look familiar to any Austen reader: two sisters, Jane and Melody. Neither will have a great dowry, but both would like to marry their gentlemanlike neighbor. Then a handsome sea captain comes to the village, as does a mysterious artist. Secrets are discovered; tears are shed. In the end, they find husbands.

The twist is that magic exists in this world. Glamour, it's called; you use it to spin illusions. Because glamour is tiring, it is mostly used for interior decorating and party tricks. It's one of the accomplishments that young ladies are expected to know. In fact, magic is fairly banal and inconsequential, like the other things that women are allowed to occupy themselves with.

This book could have exactly the same plot and ending if there were no magic, which is really a problem for a fantasy novel. Also, the whole premise also seems really doubtful to me: if magic were real, would this setting even exist? If magic were real, is making the parlor look like a forest glade the best use for it you can think of? Even if it's only good for illusions, would not inventors, statesmen, and entrepreneurs of all kinds have poured time, money, and effort into developing applications for it? Would anyone have the resources left to invent the chronometer or steam engines? Would Jane Austen's world have come to pass?

To sum up: I found Shades of Milk and Honey unconvincing and unsatisfying. But if, unlike me, you enjoy Jane Austen pastiches, you might try it.

Monday, November 15, 2010

Voyage of the oh, I don't think so

I am not a curmudgeon. I've loved movies based on beloved books. I've even found movies that improved upon their base material (good riddance, Tom Bombadil).

But when it comes to the latest Chronicles of Narnia movie, The Voyage of the Dawn Treader? No, no, a thousand times no.




The Voyage of the Dawn Treader by C.S. Lewis is not an action-packed adventure. It's full of incident, but it is a quiet book, a shining string of thoughtful wonders and Christian symbolism (quite mysterious to secular-humanist young me). It's a book that you cannot make work on film without making either a very thoughtful quiet movie, or distorting its very essence.

Take this passage, which I have abridged for length:

The first thing she noticed was a little black object, about the size of a shoe, travelling along at the same speed as the ship. Then the black thing suddenly got very much bigger and flicked back to normal size a moment later. "It's our shadow!-the shadow of the Dawn Treader," said Lucy. "Our shadow running along on the bottom of the sea. That time when it got bigger it went over a hill. But in that case, the water must be clearer than I thought! Good gracious, I must be seeing the bottom of the sea, fathoms and fathoms down."

As soon as she had said this she realised that the great silvery expanse which she had been seeing (without noticing) was really the sand on the sea-bed and that all sorts of darker or brighter patches were not lights and shadows on the surface but real things on the bottom. At present, for instance, they were passing over a mass of soft purply green with a broad, winding strip of pale grey in the middle of it. But now that she knew it was on the bottom she saw it much better. She could see that bits of the dark stuff were much higher than other bits and were waving gently. "Just like trees in a wind," said Lucy. "And I do believe that's what they are. If I were down there, that streak would be just like a road through that wood."


It goes on like this, with Lucy realizing that the sea-bed is another world, where dwell hunters and herders and great lords and ladies, and if you want to know more, you'd better get the book, because I suspect that this beautiful image of surface and depth is not going to make it into the movie.

This is the great problem with all the Narnia films. C.S. Lewis wrote simply but clearly, evoking things that come to life in the mind's eye, but that must inevitably lose all their power when deployed upon the screen. In my imagination, I can conjure a majestic Lion, the highest of all High Kings, both terrifying and compassionate. But show me a CGI lion, whose lips move and Liam Neeson's voice comes out? No.

My relationship with the works of Lewis is uneasy. Sometime in my teens I became aware that the books I had adored contained hitherto-undetected religious content. I had always understood the moral implications of the books; but the idea that Lewis had been preaching to me felt like a betrayal. When I returned to the books as an adult, I was struck by still more problems. The books are laden with unpalatable assumptions about class and race; and let us avert our eyes from the fate of poor Susan. Yet I was again seduced by Lewis' invention, his luminous prose, his power as a storyteller.

The Voyage of the Dawn Treader is my favorite of the Narnia books. If it's been a long time since you read it (or if, unthinkably, you never have) I urge you to pick it up. In spite of everything, it still shines; it really does.

Monday, August 9, 2010

Fanciful yesteryear


I love historical fiction. I love Patrick O'Brian's addictive maritime adventures. I love Dorothy Dunnett's rich and dense Lymond Chronicles. These series both do one thing very well: they immerse the reader in accurate and detailed depictions of life in a different time. It's that immersion that I love.

There's another set of historical novels that I also love - The Baroque Cycle by Neal Stephenson. I adore these three big novels, but wouldn't put them in the same category with O'Brien and Dunnett. There's plenty of very accurate, closely-researched historical detail, but Stephenson is far more playful in the way he presents historical people and events. You can't get lost in a different time if the author keeps throwing madcap historical absurdities at you.

I won't even try to give more than a brief overview of this action-packed series. It is set approximately between 1660 and 1720. There are four main characters. Daniel Waterhouse is Isaac Newton's college roommate, who becomes obsessed with the invention of a computing machine that will operate with golden punch-cards. Jack Shaftoe is an illiterate adventurer whose eventual career as a couterfeiter makes him Isaac Newton's nemesis. Eliza de la Zeur, a native of Qwglm (a land whose language has sixteen consonants and no vowels), is a financial genius, spy, and kingmaker. And Enoch Root is a mysterious, apparently-eternal and possibly backwards-living wizard/alchemist.

The series explores a dazzling array of issues, especially the history of science and mathematics, currency and finance, cryptanalysis and espionage. But there's nothing dry about Stephenson's fascination with math, codes, and economics. For instance, when Jack goes to India, he learns of a job so disgusting that I will not describe it, traditionally reserved for one particular caste. Jack promptly offers to do it for less, introducing capitalist competition and upsetting millennia of unwritten law. Or when Root, unleashing a terrifying weapon that resembles a circular saw blade on a cord, blithely misquotes Arthur C. Clarke: "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from a yo-yo." In the eighteenth century.

Stehpenson's boundlessly playful imagination never lets you get lost in the past, but the romp he takes you on through the centuries is so much fun you won't really mind. The books in the series are Quicksilver, The Confusion, and The System of the World. I enjoyed them so much I want to read them again someday - after I rest. Each one is about a thousand pages long, so don't put all three on hold at once.

Monday, July 19, 2010

What if?


What if the Axis had won World War II? Several authors have explored this premise. Philip K. Dick wrote about it in 1962 in The Man In The High Castle; Len Deighton tackled it in SS-GB in 1979. I believe that alternate-history master Harry Turtledove has written several novels with the scenario, although I admit that I have a hard time committing to Turtledove's books. There are probably lots of others.

Jo Walton has written a sensitive and powerful trio of books that examine a related premise: what if Great Britain had pursued a policy of appeasement with Germany, remaining isolated from World War II?

In Farthing it is 1949. England is apparently at peace, and several members of the upper class are gathering for a country-house party. When a prominent man is murdered, it appears to be a setup for a traditional murder-mystery. However, in this alternate England, political considerations soon override the search for truth. A scapegoat is framed for the murder; blackmail is used to get the police to go along with the official story. Apparently, even though Great Britain has avoided war, all is far from well.

In the second and third books, Ha'penny and Half a Crown, it is clear that England is sliding inexorably into fascism, and the police serve an entirely different function than solving crimes and keeping people safe. The entire trilogy is a thought-provoking portrait of a devil's bargain.

Monday, May 24, 2010

The Locke Lamora affair


In a city that is somewhat similar to Renaissance Venice -- a dirty, corrupt, dangerous, beautiful city -- a gang of con artists raise their glasses in a toast: "To us: richer and cleverer than everyone else!"

The book is
The Lies of Locke Lamora, and these thieves call themselves the Gentlemen Bastards. They steal to get rich, and because it's fun. Led by the chameleonlike Locke, they embark upon a complicated long con of a greedy nobleman. But they are too clever by half, and things go disastrously awry, putting the Gentlemen Bastards at odds with the most powerful men of the city: its all-powerful Duke; the Spider, chief of the Duke's secret police; the Capa Barsavi, leader of its criminal underworld; and a mysterious figure known only as the Grey King.

The Lies of Locke Lamora is a violent and profane series of fantastic, improbable, deliciously fun adventures. If you pick it up -- and I recommend that you do -- please be prepared for lots of gore and foul language.

Indeed, the language is so foul that I found it a little hard to find a usable quote for this blog. Here's the one I found. Locke talking to his accomplice Calo, trying out his disguise as a northern merchant, overdressed for the hot climate:


"My name," said Locke Lamora, "is Lukas Fehrwight. I am wearing clothes that will be full of sweat in several minutes. I am dumb enough to walk around Camorr without a blade of any sort. Also," he said with a hint of ponderous regret, "I am entirely fictional."

"I'm very sorry to hear that, Master Fehrwight," said Calo.


Locke stepped carefully down toward the edge of the barge, swaying at the hips like a man newly off a ship and not yet used to surfaces that didn't tilt beneath his feet. He wore the mannerisms of Lukas Fehrwight like a set of invisible clothes.
"My attendant will be along any moment," Locke/Fehrwight said ans he/they stepped aboard the barge. "His name is Graumann, and he too suffers from a slight case of being imaginary."

"Merciful gods," said Calo, "It must be catching."


Interested? Reserve the book or the audio CD.

Thursday, February 25, 2010

Song of Ice and Fire

George R. R. Martin's series A Song of Ice and Fire is a vast and complex fantasy epic with a dark and tragic edge and a twist of sardonic humor and hope. His deft characterizations allow the book to transcend expectations; his characters will haunt you. Little Bran, who climbed like a monkey over the towers of Winterfell until he saw something he shouldn't have; Tyrion Lannister, with a stunted body and a bitterly sharp intellect, unable to curb his tongue; Aria, daughter of a lord, who can't sew to save her life but who practices sword-play in secret with the butcher's boy; Jon Snow, the bastard, loved like a true-son and a favorite brother, but with none of the privileges; Daenerys, abused by her half-mad brother and sold to a foreign and barbaric-seeming people.

Each character is as vital and real as the last, and their stories intersect in surprising and fascinating ways. Martin describes events from various perspectives so convincingly that you fully understand why the characters make the choices they make, even when they lead inexorably to more trouble and tragedy. In this world, where summers and winters can last for a decade, the hard-won season of peace is cracking ominously under the threat of coming winter, sending lives askew.

There are four books published so far out of a projected seven; A Game of Thrones, A Clash of Kings, A Storm of Swords, and A Feast for Crows. Each book is a treasure, intense and long-lasting; you won't want them to end, but they will. Book 5 is overdue, and when you finish number 4, you'll be joining hordes of fans in waiting, very impatiently, for it!

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

An Oregon Author

I recently discovered that Patricia A. McKillip, one of my all-time favorite authors, was born in Salem and lives not too far from here, on the Oregon coast. (She seems to be quite private and has very little Internet presence, so I won't out her by telling you exactly where.)

I've been reading McKillip's novels since I was a teenager. She writes myth-soaked Tolkienesque fantasy, often featuring ancient mages, dangerously beautiful faerie-folk, and bewildered protagonists struggling against dark magic. Her publisher gives her books pretty, flowery covers, that might make you think they're all girlish unicorns and rainbows. But McKillip is an excellent writer with an original, elegant prose style, and her novels have great power. She's won a basketful of awards, including -- twice -- the prestigious World Fantasy Award.

My favorites are The Book of Atrix Wolfe; Alphabet of Thorn; and the Riddle-Master trilogy, with which I fell passionately in love when I was fourteen. All are highly recommended. (She has written a few contemporary novels as well, but I don't like these as much: the characters still talk like legendary kings and maidens, which makes it hard to picture them driving cars or vacuuming.)

Since learning that McKillip lives on the coast, I've started re-reading her books, trying to find Oregon there. She lived in New York's Catskill Mountains for a long time, and the truth is that most of the landscapes in her books resemble the ancient mountains and deep deciduous forests of the Northeast. However, her most recent book, The Bell at Sealey Head, is set on a wild and rocky coast.

...the cliff behind the inn, where the waves were breaking so hard they sent spume high in the air that turned again and fell as a gentle rain onto the rocks. Gulls hung in the wind, white as froth, so neatly balanced they were motionless in all that roil before they dropped a wing, caught a current, and cried out as they flew over the sea. Another bell was sounding: the channel marker tumbling about in the tide, jangling to guide one last fishing boat toward the harbor on the north side of the headland.

Yes, that sounds familiar. (And doesn't Sealey Head sound like the name of an Oregon town?)